Beer Judging and the BJCP Exam

The BJCP Guide

The Beer Judge Certification Program (BJCP) is an independent non-profit membership organization of beer judges. It was formed in 1985 through the efforts of the American Homebrewers Association (AHA) and the Home Wine and Beer Trade Association (HWBTA). Over 1500 judges are currently active in the program. The purpose of the BJCP is to promote beer literacy and the appreciation of real beer, and to recognize beer tasting and evaluation skills.

The BJCP Exam

The three-hour BJCP exam is given in two parts: essay and tasting, The essay portion, worth 70 percent of the final score, is designed to determine an individual's overall knowledge of beer and his or her ability to express the information in writing. Essay questions cover the following areas:

The tasting portion of the exam is worth 30 percent of the final score. Each candidate will judge four beers as he or she would at a competition. The prospective judge must score the beer and describe all significant aspects of it, as well as comment on style characteristics.

In preparing for the exam, you should acquire a broad understanding of beer styles, know different brewing methods and how brewing methods correlate with style and flavor. Brewing processes should be understood to the point where you can intelligently discuss various techniques and ingredients and how they may have affected the beer being sampled. Frequent tasting of commercial beers will help you gain further understanding of style differences.

Each club wanting to host an exam must get a National or Master judge to proctor the test. I have spoken to Wendy Aaronson of BURP about getting one of their judges to come assist us, and will confirm their assistance before I book a date. The exam costs $50 for first-time takers, and $30 for retakes.

Preparation for the Exam

The BJCP suggests strategies for studying for this exam, including having group study/tasting/discussion sessions. The BJCP also has a study guide available for test-takers. In preparation for our test, I will put together a study group, and make copies of the study guide for each member. I will need to ask for a $10 deposit in order to get materials for the sessions (copies, example beers, etc).

Proposed Syllabus

We should meet 10-12 times, each session should last approximately 3 hours. Each session will pair a beer style and aspect of brewing, and involve us in judging. We will use the sample questions provided by the BJCP and look to articles from the recommended reading list as well as our own experience in answering these questions.

Class 1- What is the BJCP? & overview

Class 2- Light Lagers & Malt

Class 3- Amber and Dark Lagers & Water

Class 4- Bitters and Pale Ales & Mashing

Class 5- Brown, Scottish and Strong Scotch Ales & Hops

Class 6- Stout and Porter & Yeast and Fermentation

Class 7- Barleywines and Old Ales & Brewing procedures

Class 8- German Ales, Wheat Beers and Rauchbiers & Troubleshooting I

Class 9- Strong Belgian and French Ales & Troubleshooting II

Class 10- Other Belgian Ales & Recipe Formulation

Class 11- Doctored beer seminar

Participants are encouraged to start on the recommended reading as soon as possible. We may take turns leading the discussions of styles and techniques.

Recommended Reading

  1. Michael Jackson, Beer Companion (Running Press, Philadelphia, 1993). Amazon
  2. Michael Jackson, The New World Guide to Beer (Running Press, Philadelphia, 1998). Amazon
  3. Michael Jackson, The Simon and Schuster Pocket Guide to Beer (Simon and Schuster, New York, 1996). Amazon
  4. Charlie Papazian, The Homebrewer's Companion (Association of Brewers, Boulder, CO, 1996).
  5. Dave Miller, Dave Miller's Homebrewing Guide (Garden Way Publishing, Pownal, VT 1996). Amazon
  6. Gregg Smith, The Beer Enthusiast's Guide (Storey Communications, Pownal, VT, 1994). Amazon

Advanced Reading

  1. Classic Beer Styles Series, (Brewers Publications, Boulder, CO). There are presently twelve books in this series: Amazon
    Pale Ale and Porter, both by Terry Foster;
    Continental Pilsner by Dave Miller;
    Lambic by Jean-Xavier Giunaard;
    Vienna, Maerzen, Oktoberfest by George and Laurie Fix;
    Bock by Darryl Richman;
    Scotch Ale by Greg Noonan;
    German Wheat Beer by Eric Warner;
    Belgian Ale by Pierra Rajotte,
    Stout by Michael Lewis,
    Alt by Horst Dornbusch, and
    Barleywine by Fal Allen and Dick Cantwell.
  2. Gregory J. Noonan, New Brewing Lager Beer (Brewers Publications, Boulder, CO, 1996). Not available at Amazon, I have a copy.
  3. George Fix, Principles of Brewing Science (Brewers Publications, Boulder, CO, 1989). Amazon
  4. Brewing Techniques (New Wine Press, Eugene, OR). Contains a wealth of information about the ingredients, history and flavors in beer.
  5. Zymurgy Special Issues (Association of Brewers, Boulder, CO). Of particular use are the 1997 issue on Hops, the 1995 issue on Grains, the 1991 issue on Traditional Beer Styles, the 1989 issue on Yeast and the 1987 issue on Troubleshooting. Judging Levels

Judges vary widely in their skill and experience. As a result, the BJCP recognizes various levels of accomplishment. An individual's level of certification is determined by two factors: exam score and experience points earned through BJCP registered and AHA sanctioned competitions. The different levels and the criteria for achieving them are outlined below.

Advancing in the BJCP

Because both exam scores and experience points determine the level of recognition achieved in the BJCP, a judge should strive to meet both types of criteria on an ongoing basis. A judge may wish to retake the exam at a reduced fee in order to achieve the higher score necessary to advance to the next level. A judge will be placed on an inactive list if no experience points are recorded for two years. After two years on the inactive list, a judge will be dropped from the BJCP roster. This policy encourages judges to maintain their skills and assures competition organizers that they are using experienced judges with up to date knowledge of beer styles and judging practices. Upon certification by the BJCP, the judge receives a handsome certificate and a wallet-size card showing the date of award and level of recognition.

I hope that we get a dedicated group of people who want to have a good time with friends while we increase our knowledge and understanding of the beverage we love (and get cool wallet- cards to flash at saucy beertenders). Please consider studying for and taking the BJCP test with us this spring, and contact me if you have any questions-

Stasi York
stasiyork@hotmail.com